Viewing entries in
Pricing Strategy

How Time-Based Billing is Destroying the Agency Business

Comment

How Time-Based Billing is Destroying the Agency Business

If you’ve ever watched an episode of the television series Mad Men, you have no doubt noticed that advertising executive Don Draper and his colleagues were quite well paid. They worked in large, well-appointed offices and entertained the clients with lavish dinners. While the narrative behind this Emmy Award winning show is fictional, the story it tells about the nature of the agency business in the 1960s is true to life. That’s because most agencies in the Golden Age of Advertising were very healthy, profitable businesses. 

Comment

Making Money vs. Making Forecast

Comment

Making Money vs. Making Forecast

The constant forecasting and recasting of revenue is a colossal waste of time in most professional service organizations. No doubt every firm needs a periodic estimate of expected income and expenses, and the closer the estimate is to the actuals, the better. But the time devoted by senior professionals to the relentless forecasting process in most firms doesn't yield the expected incremental value. As the Scottish proverb goes, “You don’t make sheep fatter by weighing them more often.” 

Comment

The Beautiful Questions of Value

Comment

The Beautiful Questions of Value

Most conversations between buyers and sellers start with the wrong question. Buyers are likely to prematurely ask “How much?” Your job is to postpone the answer and ask a beautiful question…

Comment

You Have an Unfinished Business Model

Comment

You Have an Unfinished Business Model

If you work in the world of professional services — advertising, law, accounting, architecture, etc. — it’s more than likely your firm is missing a critical element in its business model. Without it, you're dealing with self-inflicted roadblocks to your long-term financial success…

Comment

Don't Act Like a Commodity

Comment

Don't Act Like a Commodity

No doubt you’ve heard a friend in business say something like, “That’s fine for Apple or BMW, but we’re selling a commodity.” Even if your friend works for a grain processing company, that’s a remarkably misguided statement. And if you work in professional services, it unconscionable to believe that what you do is difficult to distinguish…

Comment

How Agile Inspires Better Margins

Comment

How Agile Inspires Better Margins

What do effective pricing and agile development have in common? Quite a lot, it seems. Especially in the world of professional services, where most firms are stuck in an industrial age model of adding up their hours (costs) and calling it a price. 

Comment

Dealing With Procurement? Just Say No

Comment

Dealing With Procurement? Just Say No

The hue and cry raised by agencies today as they deal with the professional buyers of their services is louder than ever. With each new business win, a short-lived celebration is soon tempered by the demands from client procurement managers who not only seek to negotiate lower pricing (which is their job), but increasingly endeavor to dictate to agencies exactly how they should sell, package and price their services.

Comment

You Know Your Costs, But Do You Know Your Value?

Comment

You Know Your Costs, But Do You Know Your Value?

Most professional firms walk into pricing discussions armed with an understanding and defense of their costs (spreadsheets populated with people and estimated hours) but have spent virtually no time or energy comprehending the value they’re about to create for their client. It’s little wonder that the senior executives at most professional firms are easy prey for the tactics of professional buyers in compensation and contract negotiations.

Comment

Who Are the Guardians of Value in Your Firm?

Comment

Who Are the Guardians of Value in Your Firm?

As marketers continue to trim budgets and cut costs, agencies are struggling to grow their revenues and improve their margins. The reaction of most firms is to attempt to do a better job of estimating, recording and billing for the agency's time. That is not the answer.

Comment

What Timesheets Don't Tell You

Comment

What Timesheets Don't Tell You

What Timesheets Don't Tell You

LinkedIn Article by Tim Williams 
January 31, 2017

Is it possible to run a successful professional service firm without billing for the hours recorded on timesheets? Apparently so, as thousands of the most successful ones have already abandoned the idea of selling inputs and instead focus on outputs and outcomes.

But even those professionals who concede that time-based billing is a suboptimal way to capture value fret that without timesheet data, they’ll lose the essential information they need to run their business. Given that time tracking has become so ubiquitous in professional firms, most professional managers have been brought up to believe it’s the only tool they have to manage their resources and profitability.

Indeed, because time reports look so precise and scientific, they create the illusion of providing crucial metrics. But the reality is timesheets tell you almost nothing about the measurements that really matter in knowledge work. And if you accept (as most informed managers do) that timesheets are notoriously inaccurate, their true utility is marginal at best. (Not to mention the many negative effects time tracking produces in terms of internal motivation and misalignment of economic interests with clients, but that’s another story.)

To illustrate what timesheets do and don’t tell you, take the following 10-question quiz:

TRUE OR FALSE

Timesheets are an effective measurement of:

TRUE OR FALSE  1. COST OF COMPLETING A PROJECT

TRUE OR FALSE    2. QUALITY OF THE WORK COMPLETED

TRUE OR FALSE    3. CLIENT SATISFACTION

TRUE OR FALSE    4. DEGREE OF PROJECT COMPLETION

TRUE OR FALSE    5. EXTENT OF INTERNAL COLLABORATION

TRUE OR FALSE    6. SCOPE COMPLIANCE

TRUE OR FALSE    7. EFFECTIVENESS OF INDIVIDUALS OR TEAMS

TRUE OR FALSE    8. PROMISES KEPT AND DEADLINES MET

TRUE OR FALSE    9. EFFECTIVENESS OF FIRM’S RECOMMENDATIONS

TRUE OR FALSE    10. ABILITY TO FOLLOW DIRECTIONS AND COMPLY WITH COMPANY POLICY

Now let's analyze these questions one at a time.

1. COST OF COMPLETING A PROJECT

False.  Even if timesheets were accurate (which we know they're not), adding up time spent on a project does not provide what a cost accountant would consider an actual cost. In economic terms, time is not a cost. Salaries are a cost. Rent is a cost. Office supplies are a cost. Time is not a cost. In knowledge work, time is a constraint.

2. QUALITY OF THE WORK COMPLETED

False. Hopefully, no explanation is needed here. It would be dead wrong to conclude that “more time” on a project necessarily means better quality.

3. CLIENT SATISFACTION

False. If client satisfaction is correlated to time spent in any way, it would only be in a negative sense. What do clients want? Fewer billable hours. What do firms want? More billable hours.

4. DEGREE OF PROJECT COMPLETION

False. Timesheets tell you nothing about the degree of completion on a project. No matter that 5 hours were estimated for the discovery phase and 4.5 of them have already been spent; the responsible party may just be getting started.

5. EXTENT OF INTERNAL COLLABORATION

False. Internal collaboration is desirable, but timesheets will never tell you if it’s happening. Indeed, they are likely to hide it, given the economic disincentive for too many people to “spend time” on a project, or meet together in a conference room to solve a problem.

6. SCOPE COMPLIANCE

False.  Ask a project management professional in an engineering firm what it means to manage the scope of a project and they will say nothing about hours. A project is “in scope” if deadlines are being met, hard costs are within budget, and the client hasn’t requested changes or additions beyond the original Scope of Work — period — and hours logged don’t give you the answers to any of those questions. If the exercise of monitoring time “overages” tells you anything (remember, timesheets aren’t accurate), it would be that either the firm is poor at estimating or the project team is poor at time management — not whether the project is staying within the agreed-upon scope.

7. EFFECTIVENESS OF INDIVIDUALS OR TEAMS

False. Timesheets tell you nothing about individual or team performance, and provide no basis for helping teams or individuals improve their professional effectiveness.

8. PROMISES KEPT AND DEADLINES MET

False. As a manager, can you rely on timesheets to help gauge whether deadlines are being met? Does a timesheet tell you if the firm is keeping its promises to clients? Or if associates are honoring their commitments to one another? Does a time report help you know when the company is truly over capacity, or does it mostly reflect internal perceptions of being busy?

9. EFFECTIVENESS OF FIRM'S RECOMMENDATIONS

False. Nothing in the time tracking system even attempts to measure the thing professional services firms get hired for in the first place: effectiveness.

10. ABILITY OF STAFF TO FOLLOW DIRECTIONS AND COMPLY WITH COMPANY POLICY

True. In the final analysis, this is really the only accurate (and dubiously useful) information provided by the timesheet system. What proportion of your staff is willing to do as they’re told and submit a regular timesheet? If you’re looking for a leading indicator of obedience, you might as well ask them all to wear non-matching socks and see who’s willing to comply.

 Of the measurements above that most professionals would agree are vital to success, what kind of tools do we have to measure them? For many firms, the answer is almost none. Instead, we keep peering through the wrong end of the telescope, looking for ever more precise ways of measuring the wrong thing.

If you want your clients to start hiring and paying you based on the right things — your talent, expertise, and effectiveness — instead of having the lowest hourly rate, keep in mind the insightful observation of behaviorist Dan Ariely: “You are what you measure.”

Comment

An Obituary for the Billable Hour

Comment

An Obituary for the Billable Hour

Here lies the billable hour. It died a slow and predictable death, brought about by natural causes. The billable hour would have turned 100 in just a few years. Born in 1919, it is the offspring of Boston lawyer Reginald Heber Smith, who was hoping his creation would help him diagnose and correct certain ills in his firm.

Comment

To Make More Money, Take More Risk

Comment

To Make More Money, Take More Risk

When creating an investment portfolio for retirement, no reasonable person would put all their money just in gold, just government bonds, or just stocks (especially in today’s economic climate). In a professional services firm, your client compensation agreements are your most important financial asset. If they are all based on the same remuneration system — just fees based on hours, for example — it means you’re not diversifying your portfolio, and by definition not maximizing your firm's profitability.

Comment

Rebelling Against Billable Time

Comment

Rebelling Against Billable Time

Since the turn of the century, a global pricing revolution has been underway. Companies of all stripes now employ not just finance professionals who calculate the cost of products and services, but also pricing professionals who know how to determine the value

Comment