JOMO for Agencies: The Joy of Missing Out

By Tim Williams

Name a widely-admired agency and it’s certain one of their leading qualities is their willingness to say “no.” They say no to CMOs who want to dictate creative work, to junior brand managers who try to second-guess strategies, and most importantly, to new business prospects that don't fit their ICP -- Ideal Customer Profile.

For the vast majority of agencies, the primary criteria for a prospective client has almost exclusively to do with money. If the brand is alive and breathing, and if the marketing team has a sufficient budget, they’re welcomed as a client.

Smart agencies consistently play to their strengths, careful to only prospect for clients that match their core competencies and market expertise. These agencies have a well-defined positioning strategy defined primarily by two key dimensions:

• What types of business and marketing problems our firm is best suited to solve.

• Who the agency knows best in terms of industries, business sectors, or audiences.

The ideal client is in an industry in which the agency has deep expertise (“Who”) and has a problem the agency is perfectly suited to solve (“What”).

When there’s this kind of match, agencies can do their very best work. They’re able to deliver meaningful strategies, inspirational creative work, and precise targeting. The agency is essentially running on all cylinders.

Deep Layers of Benefits to the Agency

The tip of this iceberg represents a good “product/market fit.” But beneath it all is an entire constellation of benefits to the agency and its people:

1. Faster and better. Because the agency is playing to its strengths, it can often arrive at a brilliant solution faster than agencies who have little experience either in this type of industry or with this type of problem. If the agency applies a modern pricing approach that is untethered from hourly billing, this means a higher profit margin.

2. Streamlined operations. The agency avoids paying what we call the “complexity tax” that comes with trying to work your way through problems you’re not well-suited to solve. Unless your new client is a good match with your positioning strategy (types of problems you solve + types of industries you know) the engagement will be littered with false starts, endless revisions, and killed work. This drains your margin to near zero.

3. Professional satisfaction. The team working on “perfect fit” clients experiences a higher degree of professional satisfaction. Because the agency has been hired for its experience, your people are treated as experts, not worker bees. In knowledge businesses, elite performers are drawn to mastery. A firm that stands for everything offers no clear developmental arc. A firm that stands for something specific provides a pathway to expertise. Top-tier strategists, creatives, and other professionals want to deepen their capabilities in a defined arena, not constantly context-switch across disconnected categories.

4. Enhanced reputation. Finally, working for clients who match your positioning strategy helps build the agency’s reputation for its focused offering and adds relevant case studies to the agency’s portfolio. When a firm repeatedly solves a narrow class of problems in a defined market, authority builds. Referrals become more precise, prospects arrive pre-qualified, and the firm’s narrative becomes more coherent. By contrast, diversified firms generate scattered proof points that fail to reinforce one another. Focus creates a reputational flywheel; diffusion produces noise.

Recommended by LinkedIn

The Joy of Missing Out

The satisfaction that comes from politely saying no is sometimes referred to as “the joy of missing out” — the idea that staying true to your core creates a real sense of accomplishment and satisfaction.

In the Tonya Dalton book “The Joy of Missing Out: Living More by Doing Less,” Dalton makes the argument that when we focus our energies on what we know and do best, we save our “decision capital” for the important work that will make a real difference.

This is the deeper meaning of the joy of missing out. Fear of missing out chases revenue. Joy of missing out builds enterprise value. Fear of missing out optimizes for activity. Joy of missing out optimizes for advantage. Fear of missing out maximizes optionality. Joy of missing out maximizes leverage.

The urgency of this discipline becomes even sharper in the age of AI. Automation disproportionately commoditizes repeatable, mid-level services. Production work becomes faster and cheaper. Generic strategic frameworks become widely accessible. Surface-level differentiation collapses.

What survives are proprietary insights, deep category knowledge, and integrated solution ecosystems that cannot be easily replicated. AI accelerates the collapse of the middle distance. Firms clinging to broad, undifferentiated offerings will feel margin pressure first and hardest. Focus, in this environment, is not aesthetic — it’s existential.

The Foundation of Your Business Model

Having a clearly-defined value proposition is the foundation of every decision you’ll ever make, including:

• What new technologies should we be adopting?

• What new talent should we be hiring (or terminating)?

• What new products, programs or platforms should we be developing?

• What new investments or acquisitions should we be making?

And overall, how should we be deploying our limited time and resources in a way that optimizes the success of our firm?

When your firm commits to a defined set of problems for a defined market, business decisions are clear. Client qualification becomes simpler and investment priorities become obvious.

Prospective clients, consciously or unconsciously, interpret a polite "no" as evidence they're working with a firm that knows what it stands for. An agency's willingness to walk away is not merely a negotiation tactic—it's a market signal. In a category crowded with firms eager to comply, the disciplined firm stands apart simply by not chasing every dollar.

Everything — literally everything — revolves around your value proposition. Strategic restraint, properly understood, isn’t limiting — it’s liberating.